Penalty Shootouts: Rules, History and the Psychology of the Spot

Under the penalty shootout rules in football’s Laws of the Game, each team takes five kicks from the penalty mark, alternating, and the side that scores more wins. If it’s still level after five each, the shootout goes to sudden death, one kick per team, until one scores and the other doesn’t. Only players on the pitch at the end of the match can take part, and nobody can take a second kick until every eligible team-mate has taken one.
That’s the short version. The full picture takes in a coin toss, strict rules on where the goalkeeper stands, a surprisingly recent law change about slipping kickers, and more than fifty years of heartbreak, heroics and very nervous walks from the halfway line.
Quick answer
- The official name is kicks from the penalty mark, and it’s covered by Law 10 of the IFAB Laws of the Game.
- Each team takes five kicks, alternating. If still level, it goes to sudden death.
- Only players on the field at the end of the match (including extra time) are eligible, and teams must have equal numbers.
- Every eligible player must take a kick before anyone takes a second.
- There are no rebounds: once the ball stops moving forward, goes out or is saved, that kick is over.
- Shootouts decide a match but don’t count as goals: the official result is a draw.
Penalty shootout rules, step by step
A shootout only happens when a match has to produce a winner and is level after normal time, and usually after extra time too. Some competitions skip extra time and go straight to penalties. The procedure itself is the same everywhere because it’s written into the Laws of the Game by the IFAB.
The coin tosses
The referee tosses a coin to decide which goal will be used. This one can be overruled for practical reasons, such as safety, the state of the pitch or lighting. Then there’s a second coin toss, and the captain who wins it chooses whether their team kicks first or second.
Most captains choose to go first. The idea is that the team kicking second is always playing catch-up, which adds pressure. Whether that advantage is real is one of the most debated questions in football statistics, and we’ll come back to it.
Who can take a kick
Only players who were on the field at the end of the match, or temporarily off it (for example, receiving treatment), are eligible. Substitutes who didn’t come on can’t take part. If one team has more players than the other, perhaps because of a red card, the team with more must reduce its numbers to match, and the captain tells the referee who’s been left out.
The goalkeeper is the one exception to the “no fresh players” rule. If a keeper is injured and can’t continue during the shootout, they can be replaced by a named substitute, if the team hasn’t used its full allocation of substitutions, or by one of the players excluded to equalise numbers. A replaced goalkeeper can’t come back, and can’t take a kick.
The order of kicks
Teams take kicks alternately. Each kick must be taken by a different player, and every eligible player must take a kick before anyone can take a second. In practice that means a shootout that runs long enough will see goalkeepers stepping up. The 11th kicker is often the keeper, and the 12th player might be the team’s best penalty-taker going round again.
There’s no need to declare the order in advance to the referee, although coaches always write it down. The kicker and the goalkeeper are the only players allowed in the penalty area; everyone else waits in the centre circle, apart from the other team’s goalkeeper, who stands on the goal line at the junction with the edge of the penalty area.
How a kick ends
Here’s where shootouts differ from an ordinary penalty during play. A kick is over when the ball stops moving, goes out of play or the referee stops play for an offence. There’s no follow-up, no rebound and no tap-in. The ball can hit the post, bounce off the keeper and still go in, and that counts as a goal. But if it hits the bar and drops into the six-yard box, the kick is missed, whoever is standing there.
Best of five, then sudden death
If, before both teams have taken five kicks, one team has scored more than the other could possibly reach, the shootout ends. If it’s 3-0 after three kicks each, for example, it’s over. After five each with scores level, teams keep taking one kick each until one scores and the other misses, with the same number of kicks taken.
The goalkeeper’s rules
Goalkeepers in a shootout have some freedom, but the Laws are strict about where they stand. The keeper must stay on the goal line, between the posts and facing the kicker, until the ball is kicked. At the moment of the kick, at least part of one foot must be touching, in line with or behind the goal line. That “one foot” wording came in from 2019 and was designed to make the law clearer and easier to enforce with VAR.
Keepers can wave their arms, bounce on the line and move from side to side. They can’t touch the posts, crossbar or net to distract, and they can’t behave in a way that disrespects the game, such as delaying or taunting the kicker.
What happens if the keeper moves early?
If the goalkeeper comes off their line too early and the kick is missed or saved, the kick is retaken. If the kick goes in anyway, the goal stands. In a shootout, a keeper’s first offence brings a warning, and further offences bring a caution. That’s tighter than the general rule during play and reflects how often keepers were seen creeping off their lines before the change.
What about the kicker?
Kickers can feint during the run-up, stutter, stop and start. What they can’t do is feint to kick the ball once they’ve completed the run-up. In a shootout, a kicker’s offence means the kick is recorded as a miss and the kicker may be cautioned. Kicking the ball backwards to a team-mate, which is legal in some ordinary penalty routines, is pointless here because no one else can touch it.
The double touch and the Julián Álvarez rule
One of the most recent changes to the shootout laws came after a slip. In the Champions League round of 16 in March 2025, Atlético Madrid’s Julián Álvarez slipped as he took his kick in the shootout against Real Madrid. The ball went in, but VAR showed his standing foot had brushed the ball first. Under the Laws as they stood, the goal was ruled out, and Real Madrid went on to win the shootout 4-2.
The IFAB moved quickly. From June 2025, an accidental double touch in a shootout that results in a goal is retaken, rather than ruled a miss. If the accidental double touch doesn’t lead to a goal, the kick is recorded as missed. The 2026/27 Laws of the Game formally include this wording. A deliberate second touch is still an offence. You can read the current Laws on the IFAB website.
A short history of the penalty shootout
Before shootouts, drawn knockout matches were settled by replays or, if that was impossible, the toss of a coin. Italy reached the final of the 1968 European Championship by winning a coin toss against the Soviet Union after a goalless semi-final. Nobody thought that was a satisfying way to go out.
The IFAB approved kicks from the penalty mark in 1970, and they spread quickly through club and international football. Within a few years they were deciding major finals.
Panenka, 1976
The first major international tournament final settled by a shootout was the 1976 European Championship final in Belgrade, between Czechoslovakia and West Germany. Antonín Panenka scored the winning kick by chipping it gently down the middle as Sepp Maier dived. The style of penalty still carries his name.
The first World Cup shootout, 1982
The World Cup’s first shootout came in the 1982 semi-final between West Germany and France in Seville, a match better known for Harald Schumacher’s collision with Patrick Battiston. West Germany won the shootout, the start of a remarkable record: Germany have never lost a shootout at a men’s World Cup.
Finals decided from the spot
| Match | Year | Winner on penalties | Memorable moment |
|---|---|---|---|
| European Championship final | 1976 | Czechoslovakia | Panenka’s chip |
| European Cup final, Steaua Bucharest v Barcelona | 1986 | Steaua Bucharest | Helmuth Duckadam saved all four Barcelona kicks |
| World Cup final, Brazil v Italy | 1994 | Brazil | Roberto Baggio’s miss over the bar |
| Champions League final, Liverpool v AC Milan | 2005 | Liverpool | Jerzy Dudek’s wobbling legs on the line |
| World Cup final, Italy v France | 2006 | Italy | David Trezeguet hit the bar |
| Champions League final, Manchester United v Chelsea | 2008 | Manchester United | John Terry slipped; Edwin van der Sar saved from Nicolas Anelka |
| Euro 2020 final, Italy v England | 2021 | Italy | Gianluigi Donnarumma’s saves at Wembley |
| World Cup final, Argentina v France | 2022 | Argentina | Emiliano Martínez’s save and Gonzalo Montiel’s winner |
The Istanbul final is worth reliving in full. Liverpool came back from 3-0 down at half-time, and Dudek’s antics on the line became part of the legend. Our Liverpool vs AC Milan 2005 highlights show the whole story. The 2022 World Cup final, with Lionel Messi and Kylian Mbappé trading goals before the shootout, is on our Argentina vs France highlights page.
The psychology of the spot
Taking a penalty in a shootout should be easy. The ball is 11 metres (12 yards) from goal, the keeper has to guess, and professional players score from there in training all the time. And yet top players miss. The difference is almost entirely in the head.
The long walk
Players wait in the centre circle and walk alone to the penalty area. It’s a long way to think. Researchers who study shootouts, most notably the Norwegian psychologist Geir Jordet, have looked at how players behave on that walk and before the kick. One recurring finding is that players who rush, taking the kick very quickly after the whistle, tend to perform worse. It looks like an attempt to escape an uncomfortable situation rather than a plan.
Does going first help?
An influential study published in 2010 suggested teams kicking first won around 60 per cent of shootouts. Later research with bigger samples found the advantage much smaller, or hard to separate from chance. The IFAB was interested enough to trial an alternative “ABBA” order, like a tennis tie-break, in 2017, including at the Community Shield. It was dropped the following year.
Goalkeeper mind games
Keepers have become far more active in shootouts. Some study kickers’ habits and keep notes in their water bottles. Others talk to kickers, delay, or celebrate saves wildly to put pressure on the next opponent. Emiliano Martínez became the most famous example during Argentina’s 2022 World Cup run.
The most famous tactical twist came at the 2014 World Cup. Netherlands coach Louis van Gaal brought on substitute goalkeeper Tim Krul just before the shootout in the quarter-final against Costa Rica. Krul saved two kicks and the Dutch went through. It was a bold move, and it only works if a substitution is still available, because Krul had to come on before the end of extra time.
England’s long struggle
No country’s relationship with penalties has been picked over as much as England’s. They lost World Cup shootouts in 1990, 1998 and 2006, and European Championship shootouts in 1996, 2004, 2012 and the Euro 2020 final. The turning point came at the 2018 World Cup, when they beat Colombia on penalties, and at Euro 2024 they scored all five against Switzerland. The FA put real work into preparation, from practising the walk to choosing kickers by their composure as well as their technique.
Penalty techniques you will see
There are two broad ways to take a penalty. Most kickers are keeper-independent: they pick a spot and hit it, whatever the goalkeeper does. A smaller group are keeper-dependent: they wait for the keeper to commit and then place the ball the other way, often with a stuttering run-up. Jorginho and Bruno Fernandes are well-known modern examples of the second style.
Then there’s the Panenka, the chip down the middle. It’s a statement of nerve, because if the keeper stays upright, the kicker looks foolish. Andrea Pirlo’s Panenka against England at Euro 2012 is one of the best-remembered examples, and Zinedine Zidane scored one in the 2006 World Cup final during normal time.
Common myths and misunderstandings
“Shootout goals count in the scoreline”
They don’t. A match settled on penalties is recorded as a draw, with the shootout result noted separately, for example 3-3 (Argentina won 4-2 on penalties). Shootout goals don’t count towards a player’s goal tally.
“You can score from the rebound”
Not in a shootout. The kick is over once the ball is saved, goes out or stops moving forward. This is the most common source of confusion for fans used to ordinary penalties.
“Teams can bring on fresh penalty specialists”
Only players on the field at the end of extra time can take kicks. A specialist has to be brought on before the final whistle, which is why coaches sometimes make substitutions in the last minute of extra time. The goalkeeper is the only position that can be replaced during the shootout, and only through injury.
“It’s a lottery”
Luck plays a part, but preparation, technique and composure clearly matter. Teams that practise, analyse opponents and manage the psychological side tend to do better over time. Germany’s record, and England’s improvement, both point that way.
Frequently asked questions
How many penalties are taken in a shootout?
Each team takes five kicks, alternating. If it’s still level after five each, the shootout goes to sudden death, one kick each, until there’s a winner.
Can a goalkeeper take a penalty in a shootout?
Yes. Goalkeepers are eligible like any other player and often take a kick in long shootouts, because every eligible player must take one before anyone takes a second.
What happens if the goalkeeper moves off the line early?
If the kick is missed or saved, it’s retaken. The keeper gets a warning for a first offence in a shootout and a caution for any further offences. If the kick goes in, the goal stands.
Can you score a rebound in a penalty shootout?
No. Once the ball is saved, goes out of play or stops moving, the kick is finished. There are no follow-ups.
Who decides which team goes first?
The referee tosses a coin, and the captain who wins the toss chooses whether to kick first or second. A separate toss decides which goal is used, unless the referee chooses for safety or pitch reasons.
When was the penalty shootout introduced?
The IFAB approved kicks from the penalty mark in 1970. The first World Cup shootout was in 1982, and the first European Championship final decided this way was in 1976.
For more on how knockout football works at the top level, have a look at our guide to the Champions League format, or browse our classic highlights for some of the most dramatic finals ever played.
Comments