Skip to content
Football

How VAR Works in Football: Rules, Reviews and Controversies

How VAR Works in Football: Rules, Reviews and Controversies – Predict the Pitch

VAR, the video assistant referee, is a team of match officials who watch every incident on replay and can tell the referee when they have made a clear and obvious error in a match-changing decision. Here is how VAR works in one sentence: it checks goals, penalties, direct red cards and cases of mistaken identity, and it only steps in when the referee has got something clearly wrong or missed a serious incident altogether.

That last part is the bit most fans forget. VAR was never designed to re-referee the whole game. It is a safety net for the big calls, and the rules around when it can step in, how it communicates and who has the final say explain most of the controversy it creates.

Quick answer

  • VAR can intervene in four situations: goals, penalty decisions, direct red cards and mistaken identity. From 2026/27 the Laws also allow checks on clearly wrong second yellow cards, and competitions may let VAR check wrongly awarded corners.
  • The test is “clear and obvious error” or “serious missed incident”. Marginal judgement calls should stay with the on-field referee.
  • The referee always makes the final decision. VAR advises; the referee decides.
  • Factual matters such as offside or whether the ball went out can be corrected straight from the VAR room. Subjective calls usually go to an on-field review at the pitchside monitor.
  • VAR is run under the IFAB’s VAR protocol, which forms part of the Laws of the Game.

Who the VAR team are

When people say “VAR” they usually mean one person, but it is really a small team sitting in a video operation room, often miles from the stadium. In the Premier League, the hub is at Stockley Park in west London.

The team normally includes:

  • The VAR: a qualified referee who leads the review and speaks to the on-field referee.
  • The assistant VAR (AVAR): watches the live feed while the VAR is busy with a replay, so nothing in the game is missed. Some competitions add a second AVAR to focus on offside.
  • Replay operators: technicians who find the best camera angles and cue up footage quickly.

The VAR team can see every broadcast camera, often in slow motion and from multiple angles. What they can’t do is make the decision themselves on anything subjective. That belongs to the referee.

What VAR can review: the four match-changing situations

The VAR protocol limits video review to decisions that change the course of a match. The four classic categories are below, followed by the changes that arrived in 2026.

SituationWhat VAR checksTypical example
GoalsOffside, fouls or handball by the attacking side in the build-up, ball out of play, ball over the lineA goal ruled out because the scorer was offside in the move
PenaltiesWhether a foul or handball happened, and whether it was inside or outside the areaA penalty awarded after the referee missed a trip
Direct red cardsSerious foul play, violent conduct, spitting, biting, denying an obvious goalscoring opportunityA yellow upgraded to a red after replays show studs to the shin
Mistaken identityThe wrong player booked or sent offA red card moved from one defender to the actual offender
Second yellow cards (from 2026/27)Whether a second caution that produced a red card was clearly wrongA sending-off cancelled because the second “foul” was a fair tackle

The 2026 changes

At its annual general meeting in February 2026, the IFAB widened the VAR protocol. VAR may now review a red card that came from a clearly incorrect second yellow, and it may step in when the referee penalises the wrong team for an offence and the wrong player is cautioned or sent off. Competitions can also choose to let VAR check a corner kick that was wrongly awarded, provided the check is instant and doesn’t hold up the restart.

Not every league takes up every option. The Premier League confirmed for 2026/27 that it would use VAR for second yellow cards that lead to a red, but it declined the optional corner-kick check. If you are watching a different competition, it is worth checking which version it uses.

What VAR does not cover

A first yellow card can’t be reviewed. Neither can a free kick in midfield, a throw-in going the wrong way or a goal kick that should have been a corner (unless the competition has adopted the corner option). This frustrates fans, but the reason is deliberate: if every decision were reviewable, matches would barely flow.

How VAR works, step by step

Every incident goes through the same basic process. Most of it happens silently, which is why you will often see a goal celebrated and then a short pause before the restart.

  1. The referee makes a decision on the pitch. The protocol requires a decision first. The referee can’t give “nothing” and wait for VAR to decide.
  2. VAR checks automatically. Every goal, penalty decision and red card incident is checked in the background. Most checks are quick and confirm the original call.
  3. If VAR spots a possible clear and obvious error, it recommends a review. For factual matters, the VAR can simply tell the referee the answer.
  4. For subjective calls, the referee goes to the monitor. This is the on-field review, done in the referee review area at the side of the pitch.
  5. The referee decides. They can change the decision or stick with it, then signal by drawing the shape of a TV screen in the air.

Check, review and on-field review

These three terms are often mixed up. A check is the background look at every key incident and happens constantly. A review happens when VAR thinks there may be an error and starts looking in detail with the referee. An on-field review is when the referee personally watches the replay on the pitchside monitor.

In general, offside, ball out of play and whether a foul was inside or outside the box are factual, so VAR can tell the referee directly. Whether a challenge was reckless, whether a handball was an offence, or whether contact was enough for a penalty are judgement calls, and those go to the monitor.

Play has to stop

If the ball is in play when VAR spots a problem, the referee waits for the next neutral moment to stop the game, ideally when neither team is in a promising attack. Once play has restarted after an incident, the decision usually can’t be reviewed any more. The main exception is a sending-off offence such as violent conduct, spitting or biting, or mistaken identity, which can still be looked at.

“Clear and obvious error”: the most argued-over phrase in football

The whole system rests on one test. VAR should only intervene when the referee’s decision is clearly wrong, not when it is merely one the VAR would have made differently. The phrase the IFAB uses is “minimum interference, maximum benefit”.

The problem is that “clear and obvious” means different things to different people. A penalty that looks soft at full speed can look like a clear foul in slow motion, and a foul that seems obvious in one angle can vanish in another. Slow motion also has a known side-effect: it can make contact look more deliberate or more forceful than it really was. Many protocols now ask officials to watch replays at normal speed before deciding on intensity.

Different competitions have also set the bar at slightly different heights. The Premier League has historically used a higher threshold than some European leagues, meaning fewer on-field reviews for subjective calls. That is one reason fans who watch several leagues feel VAR is applied inconsistently.

VAR and offside, including semi-automated offside

Offside is where VAR has had its biggest impact and its biggest arguments. Because offside is factual, VAR doesn’t need a monitor review. It draws lines on the image, finds the frame where the ball was played and compares the attacker with the second-last defender.

The early years brought the “armpit” era: goals disallowed by margins of a centimetre or two, decided by hand-drawn lines and a judgement over exactly which frame showed the kick. Many fans felt this was precise in a way that wasn’t truly accurate.

Semi-automated offside technology

Semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) uses tracking cameras under the stadium roof to follow players’ body points, plus data from a sensor in the ball (or optical tracking) to pinpoint the moment of the pass. It produces an offside line almost instantly and a 3D graphic that is shown to the crowd and TV viewers.

It made its World Cup debut at Qatar 2022, has been used in the Champions League since the 2022/23 season, and the Premier League switched it on in April 2025. A VAR still confirms the result, and still has to judge whether an offside player actually interfered with play or an opponent, which is a subjective call.

Famous VAR moments that shaped the system

A handful of incidents have done more to shape how fans see VAR than any rulebook.

The early milestones

The first VAR intervention in a FIFA competition came at the 2016 Club World Cup in Japan, when Kashima Antlers were awarded a penalty after a review. Two years later, the 2018 World Cup in Russia became the first World Cup with VAR, and France’s Antoine Griezmann scored the tournament’s first VAR-awarded penalty against Australia.

The Premier League held out until the 2019/20 season. Its first season was bumpy, with long offside checks and few trips to the monitor, and the league has adjusted its approach several times since.

Tottenham v Manchester City, 2019

In the 2019 Champions League quarter-final second leg, Raheem Sterling scored a stoppage-time winner for Manchester City that would have knocked Tottenham out. VAR ruled it out for offside in the build-up, and Spurs went through on away goals. Pep Guardiola’s touchline reaction became one of the defining images of VAR’s arrival in European football.

Japan v Spain, 2022

At the Qatar World Cup, Japan’s winner against Spain came from a cut-back by Kaoru Mitoma that looked out of play on TV. The VAR, using images from the goal-line camera, ruled that part of the ball was still above the line. It showed how VAR handles factual questions that the naked eye can’t settle.

Tottenham v Liverpool, 2023

In September 2023, Luis Díaz had a goal for Liverpool wrongly ruled out for offside at Tottenham. The VAR team misunderstood the on-field decision and told the referee the check was complete, so play restarted and the mistake couldn’t be corrected. PGMOL later admitted a “significant human error”, and the incident led to changes in how VAR officials communicate. Big VAR moments like this tend to dominate our fan ratings pages in the days that follow.

How VAR communicates with fans

For years, one of the loudest complaints was that supporters in the stadium had no idea what was going on. TV viewers got replays and commentary; fans in the ground got a message on the big screen saying “Check: Goal” and then waited.

That has improved. Several competitions, including FIFA tournaments, now have the referee announce the outcome of on-field reviews over the stadium speaker system. In England, PGMOL has also released audio of selected VAR conversations on television, letting fans hear the reasoning behind contentious calls. If you follow English football, our Premier League hub covers results and talking points every week.

Common VAR myths and misunderstandings

“VAR overruled the referee”

Technically, it can’t. VAR recommends, and the referee makes the final decision. Even after an on-field review, referees sometimes stick with their original call. In practice, though, most referees change their decision once they go to the monitor, which is why some critics argue the system should be reformed.

“VAR should have given that yellow card”

A first yellow card is outside VAR’s remit. Only red cards, second yellows (where the competition uses the 2026 protocol) and mistaken identity are reviewable.

“They can go back as far as they like”

Not quite. For a goal or penalty, VAR looks back over the attacking phase of play that led to it. A foul in the build-up 40 seconds earlier, before the ball went out and possession changed, is usually out of bounds.

“If the referee didn’t see it, VAR can’t act”

The opposite is true. A “serious missed incident”, such as an off-the-ball elbow the referee never saw, is exactly the kind of thing VAR exists for.

“VAR always gets it right”

VAR reduces errors on the big decisions but doesn’t remove them. Subjective calls stay subjective, and as the Díaz case showed, human communication can still fail.

Is VAR used everywhere?

No. VAR needs multiple cameras, trained officials and a video operation room, so it is mostly found at the top level: major leagues, the Champions League and other UEFA competitions, and FIFA tournaments. Many lower divisions and domestic cup ties at smaller grounds run without it. The FA Cup, for example, has only used VAR at grounds where the technology is installed.

Cost is the main barrier. That is why FIFA has trialled a simpler system, sometimes called Football Video Support, in which coaches can request a limited number of reviews per match. It is aimed at competitions that can’t afford a full VAR set-up.

For the official rules, the IFAB publishes the VAR protocol alongside the Laws of the Game. If you want to see how VAR fits into the biggest club competition, our Champions League format guide explains how the tournament is now structured.

Frequently asked questions

What does VAR stand for?

VAR stands for video assistant referee. The term covers both the official who leads the review and the wider system of replays and communication.

Can a manager ask for a VAR review?

Not under the standard VAR protocol. Players and coaches can’t request reviews, and a player who makes the TV-screen gesture to demand one can be booked. Some lower-cost trial systems do let coaches request reviews, but that is different from VAR.

Who makes the final decision, VAR or the referee?

The on-field referee always makes the final decision. VAR advises and can recommend an on-field review, but the referee chooses whether to change the call.

Can VAR review a yellow card?

A first yellow can’t be reviewed. Under the 2026 changes, VAR may review a red card that resulted from a clearly incorrect second yellow, if the competition uses that part of the protocol, and it can correct a card shown to the wrong player.

Why does VAR take so long sometimes?

Complex offside decisions, unclear camera angles and incidents involving several possible offences all add time. Semi-automated offside has made offside checks much quicker in competitions that use it.

Is VAR used in the World Cup?

Yes. VAR has been used at every men’s World Cup since 2018, and semi-automated offside was added in 2022.

VAR has changed the way big games are decided, and some of the most dramatic recent finals have featured key reviews. For a match where every decision felt huge, revisit the Argentina vs France 2022 World Cup final.

Comments

Join the discussion

Your email is never shown. Comments are checked before they appear.