Skip to content
Football

The Handball Rule in Football Explained

The Handball Rule in Football Explained – Predict the Pitch

The handball rule in football says a player commits an offence if they deliberately touch the ball with their hand or arm, if they touch it with a hand or arm that has made their body unnaturally bigger, or if they score directly from their hand or arm, even by accident. The goalkeeper is the only exception, and only inside their own penalty area.

That is the short version. The long version is why the handball rule causes more arguments than almost anything else in the game: where the arm ends, what “unnaturally bigger” means, and why a penalty is given one week and waved away the next. This guide walks through the current wording of Law 12, the history of the rule and the famous cases that shaped it.

Key facts

  • Handball is part of Law 12 (Fouls and Misconduct) in the IFAB Laws of the Game.
  • For handball purposes, the arm starts at the bottom of the armpit. A ball hitting the shoulder is not handball.
  • Not every touch of the hand or arm is an offence. The key tests are deliberate contact and whether the arm made the body unnaturally bigger.
  • Any goal scored directly from a player’s hand or arm, or immediately after the ball touches it, is disallowed, even if the touch was accidental.
  • An accidental handball by a teammate earlier in the move no longer rules a goal out.
  • The punishment is a direct free kick, or a penalty if it happens in the offender’s own penalty area, plus a card in some situations.

What the handball rule actually says

The modern handball rule has three parts. A player commits a handball offence if they:

  1. Deliberately touch the ball with their hand or arm, for example by moving the hand or arm towards the ball.
  2. Touch the ball with their hand or arm when it has made their body unnaturally bigger. The Law says a body is made unnaturally bigger when the position of the arm isn’t a consequence of, or justifiable by, the player’s body movement for that specific situation. Players take a risk when their arms are out wide.
  3. Score in the opponents’ goal directly from their hand or arm, or immediately after the ball has touched it, even if the contact was accidental. This applies to goalkeepers too.

Everything else is left to the referee’s judgement. The Laws are explicit that not every touch of the hand or arm is an offence. If the ball strikes an arm held close to the body, or an arm that is in a natural position for the movement the player was making, it should usually play on.

Where the arm begins

Until 2020 there was no official line between shoulder and arm, and referees made it up as they went along. The IFAB fixed this by defining the upper boundary of the arm as level with the bottom of the armpit. So the shoulder and the top of the upper arm, the bit covered by a T-shirt sleeve, can be used legally. That clarification stopped a lot of penalties being given for balls hitting the shoulder.

Deliberate handball versus “unnaturally bigger”

These two tests are different, and mixing them up is the root of most handball rows.

Deliberate handball

A deliberate handball is the obvious one: a player reaches out and stops the ball with their hand. Think of a defender diving to palm the ball off the line, or an attacker punching it into the net. Intent matters here, and referees look for the hand or arm moving towards the ball.

Unnaturally bigger

The second test doesn’t require intent at all. It asks whether the player’s arm was in a position that took up more space than their body movement justified. A defender sliding in with an arm flung out to the side, or jumping for a header with both arms raised above the head, is making the body bigger, and if the ball hits that arm, it is likely to be handball.

The phrase “justifiable by the player’s body movement” is the important bit. Arms move when you run, jump and turn, and the Laws accept that. Referees are asked to consider whether the arm position was a normal part of the action or something extra. It is a judgement call, which is why two referees can see the same incident differently.

Distance and deflections

Two other factors weigh heavily in practice. If the ball comes from very close range, or deflects off the player’s own body, the player has little or no chance to react, and referees are encouraged to be lenient unless the arm was clearly out. Guidance from competition organisers, including UEFA, has leaned towards not penalising a ball that deflects onto an arm from the player’s own body, unless the arm position was obviously unnatural.

Handball and goals

The rule around goals is the strictest part of the Law, because the IFAB decided football shouldn’t allow a goal to be scored by an arm, whatever the intent.

The scorer

If the scorer’s hand or arm is the last thing to touch the ball before it goes in, or the ball touches their arm immediately before they score, the goal is disallowed. Accidental or not, it doesn’t count.

Teammates and the build-up

This changed in 2021. Between 2019 and 2021 the rule was stricter: if an attacking teammate accidentally handled the ball in the build-up and a goal followed, it was ruled out. That produced some baffling decisions, and the IFAB removed it. Now an accidental handball by a teammate before a goal isn’t an offence, and neither is an accidental handball that simply creates a goalscoring chance.

A deliberate handball in the build-up by any attacking player is still an offence, and VAR can check for one as part of its review of the goal.

Punishments: free kicks, penalties and cards

A handball offence is punished with a direct free kick where it happened, or a penalty kick if an outfield player commits it in their own penalty area. Cards depend on what the handball stopped.

SituationRestartCard
Handball with no tactical effect (for example, in midfield)Direct free kickNone
Deliberate handball to stop a promising attackDirect free kick or penaltyYellow
Deliberate handball to try to score, or to try to stop a goal and failingDirect free kick, or penaltyYellow
Deliberate handball that denies a goal or obvious goalscoring opportunityDirect free kick or penaltyRed
Non-deliberate handball that denies an obvious goalscoring opportunity outside the offender’s own areaDirect free kickRed
Non-deliberate handball that denies an obvious goalscoring opportunity inside the offender’s own areaPenaltyYellow
Goalkeeper handles inside own area illegally (for example, from a deliberate back-pass)Indirect free kickUsually none

The last two rows reflect how the Laws treat the “double punishment” of a penalty plus a red card. If the handball wasn’t deliberate and a penalty is given, the offender is cautioned rather than sent off. For a deliberate handball on the line, though, it is still a red card. The full wording is in Law 12 on the IFAB website.

For a wider look at bookings and bans, our football hub collects every guide we publish on the Laws.

Goalkeepers and handball

The goalkeeper can handle the ball anywhere in their own penalty area, but there are limits. They can’t pick up a deliberate pass played to them with the foot by a teammate (the back-pass rule, introduced in 1992), or a ball thrown directly to them from a teammate’s throw-in. Doing so gives an indirect free kick to the opposition, not a penalty.

Outside their area, a goalkeeper is treated exactly like an outfield player. Handle the ball outside the box to stop an opponent racing through, and it is a direct free kick and probably a red card for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity.

A goalkeeper can’t score with their hand either. If a keeper throws the ball the length of the pitch into the opposition net, the goal isn’t given, and the restart is a goal kick.

A short history of the handball rule

For most of football’s history the rule was simple on paper: handling the ball deliberately was an offence. “Ball to hand” was fine; “hand to ball” wasn’t. The trouble was that intent is hard to read, and by the 2010s referees across different leagues were applying it very differently.

In 2019 the IFAB rewrote the rule, adding the “unnaturally bigger” test and the strict line on goals from hands and arms. Too strict, many felt. The 2019/20 season produced a run of penalties for defenders whose arms were struck from close range, and complaints from players, managers and leagues pushed the IFAB to soften it. The IFAB adjusted the wording again in 2020 (defining the armpit line) and in 2021 (removing the accidental teammate handball rule and clarifying that not every touch is an offence). The rule has stayed broadly in that shape since.

Famous handball moments

Some of the most famous moments in football history are handballs, and each one says something about the rule.

Maradona’s “Hand of God”, 1986

In the 1986 World Cup quarter-final against England in Mexico City, Diego Maradona punched the ball past Peter Shilton for Argentina’s first goal. The referee didn’t see it, and with no video review the goal stood. Under today’s rules, VAR would rule it out instantly: it is the textbook case of a goal scored directly from a hand.

Luis Suárez, 2010

In the last minute of extra time in the 2010 World Cup quarter-final, Uruguay’s Luis Suárez stopped a goal-bound header from Ghana on the line with his hands. He was sent off and Ghana were given a penalty, but Asamoah Gyan hit the bar and Uruguay won the shootout. It is the clearest example of a deliberate handball denying a goal, and of why the red card remains for that offence.

Thierry Henry, 2009

In the 2009 World Cup play-off between France and Ireland in Paris, Thierry Henry controlled the ball with his hand before crossing for William Gallas to score the goal that sent France to the 2010 World Cup. It was a deliberate handball in the build-up, the kind VAR is now designed to catch.

Montiel in the 2022 World Cup final

In extra time of the 2022 final, the ball struck the raised arm of Argentina’s Gonzalo Montiel in the area, and France were given a penalty. Kylian Mbappé scored it to complete his hat-trick and make it 3-3. It was a classic “unnaturally bigger” decision. You can watch how it unfolded in our Argentina vs France 2022 World Cup final highlights.

Euro 2024

Euro 2024 gave us examples on both sides of the line. In Germany’s last-16 win over Denmark, ball-sensor technology confirmed the ball had brushed Joachim Andersen’s outstretched hand, and Germany scored the resulting penalty. In the quarter-final, Spain’s Marc Cucurella blocked a German shot with his arm in the area and no penalty was given, a decision UEFA’s refereeing chief later said should have been a penalty.

Common handball myths

“Ball to hand is never handball”

This old phrase is out of date. A player whose arm makes the body unnaturally bigger can commit handball even if the ball hits the arm rather than the arm moving to the ball.

“If it hits the shoulder, it’s a penalty”

No. Since 2020, the arm begins at the bottom of the armpit. The shoulder is not part of the arm for handball purposes.

“All handballs in the box are penalties”

Only handball offences are. A ball striking an arm tucked into the body, or an arm used to break a fall, is usually not an offence.

“Any handball in the build-up rules out a goal”

Not since 2021. Only the scorer’s own accidental handball counts, unless a teammate’s handball was deliberate.

“Handball always means a yellow card”

Many handballs carry no card at all. Cards depend on whether the handball stopped a promising attack, an obvious goalscoring opportunity or a goal.

Frequently asked questions

Is it handball if the ball hits your arm by accident?

Not necessarily. An accidental touch isn’t an offence unless the arm made the body unnaturally bigger, or the touch led directly to the player scoring.

Where does the arm start for handball?

The upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit. Contact above that line, on the shoulder, is not handball.

Can VAR review handball?

Yes, when it is linked to a goal, a penalty decision or a red card. VAR can recommend an on-field review if the referee has made a clear and obvious error.

Is it a red card for handball on the goal line?

A deliberate handball that stops a goal is a red card, as Luis Suárez found out in 2010. A non-deliberate handball that denies a chance in the area, followed by a penalty, is a yellow.

Can a goalkeeper commit handball?

Yes, outside their own penalty area, and inside it in certain situations such as handling a deliberate back-pass. A keeper also can’t score directly with their hand.

When did the handball rule last change?

The major rewrites came in 2019, 2020 and 2021. Since then the IFAB has mainly issued clarifications rather than rewriting the core tests.

Handball calls have decided World Cups and title races, and plenty of them live on in footage. Browse our classic highlights for more of football’s most talked-about moments, or see how those controversies affected the record books in the World Cup winners list.

Comments

Join the discussion

Your email is never shown. Comments are checked before they appear.