Skip to content
Cricket

The Greatest All-Rounders in Cricket History

The Greatest All-Rounders in Cricket History – Predict the Pitch

The greatest all rounders in cricket history are usually led by Sir Garfield Sobers and Jacques Kallis, with Imran Khan, Ian Botham, Kapil Dev and Sir Richard Hadlee close behind. Sobers could do almost everything on a cricket field to world-class standard, while Kallis built numbers with bat and ball that nobody has matched over a long Test career.

Ranking them is never simple, because an all-rounder can be great in different ways. Some were batters who bowled, some were bowlers who batted, and a few were genuine match-winners in both disciplines at once. Below we set out how to judge them, profile the leading candidates with their records, and explain why the debate never quite settles.

Key facts

  • Sir Garfield Sobers scored 8,032 Test runs at 57.78 and took 235 wickets with three different styles of bowling.
  • Jacques Kallis is the only player with more than 10,000 Test runs and more than 250 Test wickets: 13,289 runs and 292 wickets.
  • The 1980s produced four great all-rounders at once: Imran Khan, Ian Botham, Kapil Dev and Richard Hadlee.
  • Kapil Dev retired in 1994 as the leading wicket-taker in Test history with 434.
  • Modern contenders include Shakib Al Hasan, Ben Stokes, Ravindra Jadeja and, in the women’s game, Ellyse Perry.

What makes a great all-rounder?

The simplest definition is a player who would get into the side for either skill alone. That bar is high. Plenty of cricketers bat a bit and bowl a bit, and they’re valuable, but the greatest all-rounders are picked twice over. Take away one discipline and they’re still in the team.

The classic statistical test compares batting average with bowling average. If a player’s batting average is higher than his bowling average, he has scored more runs per dismissal than he has conceded per wicket. It’s a rough measure, and it ignores era, conditions and role, but it’s a decent starting point. Sobers, Kallis, Imran and Keith Miller all pass it comfortably over long careers.

Then there’s the stuff numbers miss. A great all-rounder gives a captain balance: an extra bowler without losing a batter, which lets the side pick a specialist elsewhere. That’s why England built whole eras around Botham and later Andrew Flintoff and Ben Stokes. One player covering two jobs changes what the rest of the team can look like.

Batting all-rounders and bowling all-rounders

Most of the greats lean one way. Kallis was a batter first who happened to bowl at a genuine fast-medium pace. Hadlee was a bowler first, one of the very best of all time, who batted well enough to make a Test hundred and a double of 1,000 runs and 100 wickets in an English county season. Sobers is the rare case where you can’t really say which skill came first.

The greatest all rounders compared

Here are the career Test records of the leading historical candidates. These players are all retired, so the numbers are fixed.

PlayerCountryTestsRunsBat avgWicketsBowl avg
Garfield SobersWest Indies938,03257.7823534.03
Jacques KallisSouth Africa16613,28955.3729232.65
Imran KhanPakistan883,80737.6936222.81
Ian BothamEngland1025,20033.5438328.40
Kapil DevIndia1315,24831.0543429.64
Richard HadleeNew Zealand863,12427.1643122.29
Keith MillerAustralia552,95836.9717022.97

Look at the two right-hand columns together. Imran and Miller have batting averages well above their bowling averages, which is the mark of a true double threat. Kallis has the biggest raw numbers by a distance. Botham’s figures were dragged down by a long tail-off at the end of his career, which hides how devastating he was at his peak.

Sir Garfield Sobers: the complete cricketer

Ask a room of old cricket writers to name the best all-rounder ever and most will say Sobers. He scored 365 not out against Pakistan at Sabina Park in 1958, aged 21, a Test record that stood until Brian Lara passed it in 1994. He finished with 26 Test hundreds and an average close to 58.

And he bowled three ways. Sobers could open with left-arm swing, then switch to orthodox left-arm spin, then to wrist spin. Few players in history have been good enough at one of those to play Test cricket. He was also a brilliant close fielder and captained West Indies.

He’s remembered, too, for the first six sixes in an over in first-class cricket, for Nottinghamshire against Glamorgan at Swansea in 1968, off the bowling of Malcolm Nash. Sobers was knighted in 1975. The argument against him being number one is mostly that his bowling average, 34, is ordinary by the standards of the bowlers below. The argument for him is that he did all of it, at the highest level, for two decades.

Jacques Kallis: the numbers man

If Sobers is the romantic pick, Kallis is the statistical one. Over 166 Tests between 1995 and 2013 he made 13,289 runs with 45 hundreds, took 292 wickets and held 200 catches. In one-day internationals he added more than 11,000 runs and over 250 wickets.

No one else is close to that combination. Kallis batted at number three or four for most of his career, which means he faced the new ball and anchored the innings, and then bowled genuinely sharp spells with the old ball. South Africa effectively got a top-order batter and a fourth seamer in one selection for nearly two decades.

The criticism, fairly or not, is that he wasn’t always a match-winner with the ball and sometimes batted for his average rather than the situation. That’s a harsh judgement on a player whose record is staggering. Many modern analysts, comparing contributions per Test across both disciplines, put him top.

The four greats of the 1980s

For about a decade, four of the best all-rounders the game has seen were playing at the same time. Imran, Botham, Kapil and Hadlee measured themselves against each other, and fans argued about them endlessly. It was a golden age for the role.

Imran Khan

Imran turned himself from a medium-pacer into one of the fastest and most skilful bowlers in the world, a master of reverse swing. His bowling average of 22.81 is elite. In the early 1980s he was close to unplayable, taking 40 wickets in the 1982-83 home series against India.

His batting improved as his career went on, and in his last decade he averaged around 50 with the bat. He also captained Pakistan to their first World Cup in 1992, beating England in the final in Melbourne. You can relive that night through our 1992 World Cup final highlights. As a captain-all-rounder, few have matched his influence.

Ian Botham

At his peak, Botham was the most explosive cricketer in the world. In the 1980 Jubilee Test in Bombay he scored a century and took 13 wickets in the match. He reached the double of 1,000 runs and 100 wickets in 21 Tests, one of the fastest in history.

Then came 1981. At Headingley, with England following on and bookmakers offering 500 to 1, he hit 149 not out, and Bob Willis bowled England to an 18-run win. He followed it with a spell of five wickets for one run at Edgbaston and a thrilling hundred at Old Trafford. “Botham’s Ashes” is still the yardstick for one player dragging a team through a series.

Kapil Dev

Kapil was India’s first genuine fast-bowling all-rounder and their greatest captain of the era. He finished his Test career with 434 wickets, a world record at the time, and over 5,000 runs.

His defining innings came at the 1983 World Cup at Tunbridge Wells, where India were 17 for 5 against Zimbabwe. Kapil made 175 not out and India won. A fortnight later he lifted the trophy at Lord’s after beating West Indies. That run shaped Indian cricket for decades, and you can see how the trophy has moved since on our Cricket World Cup winners list.

Richard Hadlee

Hadlee is the bowler-first all-rounder of the group, and arguably the finest pure bowler of the four. He became the first man to 400 Test wickets in 1990 and finished with 431 at 22.29. His 9 for 52 against Australia at Brisbane in 1985 is one of the great Test spells.

He was also a dangerous lower-order hitter with two Test hundreds. In 1984 he did the double of 1,000 runs and 100 wickets for Nottinghamshire, the first time anyone had managed it in an English season since the county schedule was cut in 1969.

Other all-time contenders

Keith Miller

Miller, the Australian who had flown as a pilot in the Second World War, was the star all-rounder of Don Bradman’s 1948 Invincibles. He opened the bowling with Ray Lindwall, batted in the middle order and played with a swagger that made him a crowd favourite. His averages, 36.97 with the bat and 22.97 with the ball, are as good a double as anyone’s.

Wilfred Rhodes and Aubrey Faulkner

Before Test cricket was played often, the best all-rounders made their names in first-class cricket. England’s Wilfred Rhodes took 4,204 first-class wickets, still the record, and batted well enough to open for England. South Africa’s Aubrey Faulkner, an early master of the googly, was one of the best all-rounders of the Edwardian era.

Vinoo Mankad

India’s Mankad is remembered at Lord’s in 1952, when he scored 72 and 184 and bowled 97 overs in the match. A left-arm spinner and opening batter, he did the double in Tests at a speed few have matched. His name is also attached to the run-out of a backing-up non-striker, which is now simply a run-out under the Laws.

Andrew Flintoff

Flintoff’s numbers don’t put him in the top bracket, but his 2005 Ashes does. His bowling over Ricky Ponting and his hitting at Edgbaston, which England won by two runs, made him a national hero. Our Edgbaston 2005 highlights show why that summer is still talked about.

The modern all-rounders

Today’s contenders play a lot more white-ball cricket, which changes how we judge them. A T20 all-rounder might bowl four overs and face fifteen balls, and still win a game. The skills are the same, but the volume is different.

Shakib Al Hasan

Bangladesh’s left-arm spinner and left-handed batter has been the best all-rounder of his generation in one-day cricket. In January 2015 he became the first player to top the ICC all-rounder rankings in Tests, ODIs and T20Is at the same time. He has thousands of runs and hundreds of wickets in ODIs, and was outstanding at the 2019 World Cup, where he scored more than 600 runs and took 11 wickets.

Ben Stokes

Stokes’s case rests on moments as much as numbers. He made 84 not out in the 2019 World Cup final at Lord’s and then batted again in the Super Over. Six weeks later at Headingley he made 135 not out to win an Ashes Test with England’s last pair at the crease. Our Stokes at Headingley highlights are worth watching for the final hour alone. Injuries have limited his bowling, but when fit he’s a genuine fourth seamer.

Ravindra Jadeja

Jadeja has been one of the best Test all-rounders of the 2010s and 2020s, especially in India, where his left-arm spin is relentlessly accurate. He became a dependable lower-middle-order batter, and he’s one of the finest fielders of the modern era. He won the T20 World Cup with India in 2024 and retired from T20 internationals straight after.

Ellyse Perry

Any honest list should include Perry. The Australian has been the dominant all-rounder in women’s cricket for well over a decade, opening the bowling and batting in the top order across all formats. She also played football for Australia at a Women’s World Cup, an extraordinary two-sport career. Many good judges regard her as the best all-round cricketer of her generation, men or women.

Common myths about all-rounders

“The best all-rounder has the most combined runs and wickets”

Raw totals reward long careers and lots of matches. Modern players play far more international cricket than Miller or Sobers did, so totals alone are misleading. Averages, strike rates and impact per match tell you more.

“Batting average higher than bowling average proves greatness”

It’s a useful test but not the final word. Hadlee’s batting average is lower than his bowling average, yet he’s an all-time great because his bowling was so good. Equally, a part-time bowler with a few cheap wickets can pass the test without being a true all-rounder.

“All-rounders are a compromise”

Sometimes selectors pick a “bits and pieces” player who doesn’t quite merit a place for either skill. That’s where the role gets its bad name. The greats on this list are the opposite: they’d be picked for one discipline and the other comes free.

“T20 has made all-rounders less important”

If anything, the opposite is true. Franchise leagues prize players who can bowl four overs and hit hard at the end. The IPL’s Impact Player rule has changed the maths a little, since teams can bring in a specialist, but a genuine all-rounder still saves a selection.

So who is the greatest all-rounder?

If you want one name, Sobers is the traditional answer and still the most defensible. He was a great batter, a good bowler in three styles and a superb fielder. Kallis is the best choice if you trust the numbers, because nobody else has produced so much with both bat and ball over so long.

Imran is the pick if you value peak bowling plus leadership. Botham is the pick if you want the player who could win a Test single-handed more often than anyone. Kapil and Hadlee both have strong claims too. The beauty of the argument is that each answer says something about what you value in cricket.

Frequently asked questions

Who is the greatest all-rounder in cricket history?

Sir Garfield Sobers is the most common answer, followed closely by Jacques Kallis. Sobers combined a batting average near 58 with 235 wickets bowled in three styles, while Kallis has the best combined Test figures of all time.

Who has the most runs and wickets combined in Test cricket?

Jacques Kallis, with 13,289 runs and 292 wickets in 166 Tests. He’s the only player with more than 10,000 runs and 250 wickets in Tests.

Who is the best all-rounder in ODI cricket?

Kallis and Shakib Al Hasan are the strongest candidates. Both have thousands of ODI runs and well over 250 ODI wickets, with Shakib also holding a long spell as the world’s top-ranked ODI all-rounder.

Which country has produced the most great all-rounders?

England can point to Rhodes, Botham, Flintoff and Stokes, but every major nation has at least one all-time great: Sobers for West Indies, Kallis for South Africa, Imran for Pakistan, Kapil for India, Hadlee for New Zealand and Miller for Australia.

Who is the best female all-rounder?

Australia’s Ellyse Perry is widely regarded as the best all-rounder in women’s cricket history, contributing heavily with bat and ball across Tests, ODIs and T20Is for more than a decade.

What is the “double” in cricket?

Traditionally it means 1,000 runs and 100 wickets in a first-class season, or reaching milestones such as 1,000 runs and 100 wickets in a Test career. It was a common measure of an all-rounder when county seasons were longer.

Want to see some of these players at their best? Browse our classic highlights for the great matches, and the moments that settled them.

Comments

Join the discussion

Your email is never shown. Comments are checked before they appear.